From one basket to four boxes… a strategy for your tax planning

Last updated: 12/11/26



‘Don’t put all your eggs in one basket’ is the proverbial wisdom originating from at least 1615.1 We’re familiar with the concept for our investments; spread the risk, seek diversity and create a balanced portfolio.

But have you thought about diversity in terms of tax efficiency too? A method called the ‘four-box principle’ spreads your investments across four tax wrappers. Each has different tax treatment, and when used together, they can enable you to draw a significant amount of tax-efficient income each year in retirement.



The four boxes of tax planning

Here are the four tax wrappers for you to consider:

1) Your pension

Your pension is the cornerstone of your retirement planning – a powerful way to build wealth for the future. Contributions made through your employer’s pension scheme may be made from pre-tax income or receive tax relief through the pension provider, while any contributions you make outside of your employer’s scheme can benefit from up to 45% tax relief depending on your tax band (or up to 48% for some Scottish taxpayers, subject to the applicable rules and limits).

Another key advantage is that pensions are free from capital gains tax (CGT), allowing your investments to grow more tax efficiently over time. You can generally take a 25% tax-free lump sum from the age of 55 (capped at £268,275 for most people, with the age to increase to 57 in April 2028). Any further income is generally taxed at your income tax rate.2

2) An ISA

ISAs remain one of the most straightforward and tax-efficient ways to save and invest. With no tax payable on their growth or on withdrawals, you are limited only by the amount you can pay in each year. The ISA limit for the tax year 2025/26 is £20,000 a year.3

3) An offshore bond

This is where it starts to get interesting. An offshore bond is an investment product offered by insurance companies based outside the UK, often in low-tax jurisdictions. Investments inside the bond can grow largely free of UK tax, with any taxation deferred until money is withdrawn or the bond cashed in.

One of the key benefits is flexibility. You can withdraw up to 5% of your original investment each year without paying tax straight away, with the allowance accumulating if unused, up to a maximum of 100% of the original investment. Tax may become payable when a chargeable event occurs, such as surrendering the bond or making withdrawals above the available cumulative allowance.4

4) A general investment account (GIA)

A GIA is a way of investing in shares, funds and other investments. Any dividends received are subject to dividend rates of income tax, and any interest earned is taxed as savings income – though you may benefit from a £500 dividend allowance and a personal savings allowance of up to £1,000, depending on your tax band. Profits made on the disposal of investments are liable to CGT, but you can use your CGT allowance, which for 2025/26 is £3,000. That means up to £3,000 of gains per year can be taken tax free.


The ‘four box’ principle in practice

The real magic comes in having the full combination of the four tax wrappers. A case study of a couple, Mike and Judy, best demonstrates how this can work.

They have worked with a financial adviser over the years to invest £2 million using this four-box principle. We’re making assumptions here that our couple are UK residents with standard allowances and that the investment and income is projected to be suitable based on their age, lifestyle and goals. We also assume that neither has other taxable income in the year illustrated. Of course, this is an example, rather than advice.

Their target yearly income is £100,000.


The four tax wrappersSum heldStrategyAnnual withdrawalTax impact
1. Pensions£502,800Each use £12,570 personal allowance£25,140Uses full personal allowance, no tax assuming no other taxable income
2. ISAs£597,200Flexible tax free, withdraw £14,930 each£29,860No tax on ISA withdrawals or investment returns
3. GIA£400,000Withdraw £20,000£20,000Potential to use CGT and dividend allowances, although the actual tax liability depends on the investments and gains realised.
4. Offshore bond£500,0005% tax-deferred withdrawal£25,000No immediate tax liability assuming sufficient cumulative 5% allowance is available and no chargeable event is triggered
£2,000,000£100,000
A few technical notes on this case study
  • This example doesn’t include the 25% tax-free lump sums available from the pensions.
  • For the GIA, we are assuming a 3.5% annual growth rate on the £400,000 investment, which will generate around £14,000 in investment growth per year. With a combined CGT exemption of £6,000, Mike and Judy could potentially use their annual CGT exemptions when selling investments. However, the amount they can withdraw without triggering CGT depends on the original purchase costs, the gains actually realised and any other disposals during the tax year. A £20,000 withdrawal does not necessarily mean £20,000 of taxable gains.
  • A full state pension is likely to utilise most of an individual’s income tax allowance and would therefore affect the pension withdrawals illustrated above.
  • The only wrapper likely to create an annual tax bill is the GIA, depending on how it is invested and assuming the pension withdrawals fall within the available personal allowances and no offshore bond chargeable event arises. Dividend payments from stocks and shares (but not ISAs or pensions) will be taxable where they exceed the applicable allowances. You have an annual £500 tax-free dividend allowance per person.


The best plan is to plan

There are various ways to structure your finances to manage taxes efficiently, both now and for your beneficiaries. The four-box principle is just one example. Tax planning is complex, and it pays to get help.

We can offer advice that will enable you to decide and implement the best way forward for your circumstances. The earlier you start, the more successful your strategy is likely to be.
For some, that old proverb surely needs an update: ‘Don’t put all your eggs in one basket – try four boxes.’

Of course, with the Autumn Budget then approaching on 26th November 2025, we were keeping a close eye on any changes to taxation. In the meantime, we highlight the value of long-held plans and caution against taking decisions based on rumours.

Disclaimer

  • These numbers and illustrations used are just to provide an example of the way the wrappers work. Your adviser would help you structure your own plans and details such as growth and timespan.
  • Tax laws can change, so any strategy must be monitored.
  • Growth assumptions, investment returns, inflation, and charges can all alter outcomes.
  • With all financial planning, ongoing review is needed, and this sort of strategy should only be undertaken with professional advice.

1. Don’t Put All Your Eggs in One Basket – Meaning, Origin and Usage – English-Grammar-Lessons.com

2. Tax when you get a pension: What’s tax-free – GOV.UK

3. Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs): Overview – GOV.UK

4. Insurance Policyholder Taxation Manual – HMRC internal manual – GOV.UK


Important information

The content of this article is provided for general information only and does not constitute personal financial advice. While every effort is made to fact-check information and ensure accuracy at the stated date of publication, legislation, tax rates, allowances and other information may change over time.

Readers should not rely solely on this content when making financial decisions and should seek professional advice tailored to their individual circumstances. Perspective (Holden & Partners) accepts no liability for any loss arising from actions taken or decisions made based on this information.